trude: (harry potter)
[personal profile] trude
Review of Donna Tartt's The Goldfinch" where reviewer Julie Myerson doesn't like the book (fair enough) because it is a "Harry Potter tribute novel" (WTF?).

I'm currently reading The Goldfinch (It's OK. It certainly has flaws, but I enjoy reading it.) and every parallel to HP that Myerson drags up falls under "oh, that is a somewhat similar situation, only playing out in a totally different way"*, which makes me think that Myerson familiarity with HP is something like "read the first book, seen bits and pieces of the movies".

OTOH, it did strike me how one could map Tartt's debut novel The Secret History (which Myerson liked) on the HP books. Lonely boy grows up with boring middle class Californian parents/muggles! He gets the opportunity to leave this behind and go to artsy New England college/magic boarding school! At the school there is lots of wacky faculty and students/lots of wacky faculty and students! Our hero makes (new) friends/(new friends and meets a charismatic but morally ambiguous professor/Dumbledore! Horrifying and wondrous things happen!/Horrifying and wondrous things happen!

The Secret History came out a couple of years before the first HP book, but I doubt Tartt will file a lawsuit against Rowling anytime soon. (Though it would be a magnificent train-wreck if she did.)

*Obviously, Tartt and Rowling DO have some influences in common, Charles Dickens being the most obvious.

Date: 2013-12-08 09:58 am (UTC)
londonkds: (Bring back Bilis! (by redscharlach))
From: [personal profile] londonkds
The worst such case I remember hearing about was Harry Potter fans accusing Terry Pratchett of plagiarising Hogwarts as the Unseen University. He very gently pointed out in response that the "magical school" concept has been around in fiction and legend for a very long time, as well as him having written before Rowling.

Also the tendency among some fans (I suspect extreme Japanophiles but also possibly some misogynist fanboys) to claim that Hunger Games plagiarised Battle Royale, despite the fact that the concept of "schoolchildren forced into gladiatorial combat" is broad enough to support multiple works and that the worldbuilding and plots of the two works are completely different.


trude: (Default)

November 2016


Most Popular Tags

Page Summary

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Sep. 23rd, 2017 02:34 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios